Online Hoaxes, Existential Threat, And Internet Shutdown: A Case Study of Securitization Dynamics in Indonesia
Keywords:
Digitalization, Throttling, Shutdown, Hoax, Internet, Securitization Theory, IndonesiaAbstract
As one of the countries in the world with the highest growth of internet users, Indonesia is experiencing a rapid growth in social media usage. Some use social media for networking but some others use it to spread hoaxes, fake information, or disinformation. During presidential election in Indonesia in the period from 2017 to 2019, hoaxes and disinformation were widely circulated through social media and instant messaging. This phenomenon has triggered heated public debates on the nexus between digital spaces and security, which include how the online disinformation has threatened Indonesian security. For example, hoaxes were represented in the public sphere as an existential threat to Indonesian unity. Immediate question regarding this phenomenon is: why are online hoaxes and fake information represented in public spheres as a security threat? This paper argues that as a response toward the increase of online hoaxes, there were securitizing moves made by political elites and special agencies in Indonesia before and in the aftermath of the 2019 Indonesian presidential election. Employing discourse analysis of selected relevant news articles around the period of 2017-2019, this paper analyses the dynamic of the securitization of online hoaxes in Indonesia. Grounded within Securitization Theory, this paper analyses; the facilitating condition; the triumvirates of securitizations, which are the securitizing actors, the threats posed by hoaxes, and the audiences; as well as extraordinary measures executed to handle the threats; internet throttling and internet shutdown when necessary.
References
Anderson, B. (1991). Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.
APPJI. (2018). Hasil Survei Penetrasi dan Perilaku Pengguna Internet Indonesia 2018 [the 2018 Survey of Internet Penetration and Internet Users in Indonesia]. Available in https://www.apjii.or.id/content/read/39/410/Hasil-Survei-Penetrasi-dan-Perilaku-Pengguna-Internet-Indonesia-2018 (Accessed February 15, 2020).
Azali, K. (2017). “Fake News and Increased Persecution in Indonesia”. In Perspective, issue 2017, No. 61. Available in https://iseas.edu.sg/ images/pdf/ISEAS_Perspective_2017_61.pdf (Accessed Januari 31, 2020).
Bute, S. (2014). “The Role of Social Media in Mobilizing People for Riots and Revolutions: Four Case Studies in India”. In Patrut, Bogdan and Patrut, Monica (Eds), Social Media in Politics: Case Studies on the Political Power of Social Media. New York: Springer.
Buzan, B. Waever, O. & De-Wilde, J. (1998). Security: A New Framework of Analysis. Boulder CO: Lynne Rienner.
Dolinec, V. (2010). The Role of Mass Media in the Securitization Process of International Terrorism. Politické vedy, 13(2), 8-32.
Elson, R. (2001). Suharto: A Political Biography. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fetzer, J. (2004). “Disinformation: The Use of False Information”. In Minds and Machines Vol 14, p. 231–240.
Gazali, E. (2014). “Learning by Clicking: An Experiment with Social Media Democracy in Indonesia”. In the International Communication Gazette Vol. 76 (4-5): pp 425-439.
Gunawan, B. & Ratmono, B. (2018). Kebohongan di Dunia Maya: Memahami Teori dan Praktikpraktiknya di Indonesia [Lies in Cyberspace: Understanding the Theory and Its Practices in Indonesia]. Jakarta: Kepustakaan Populer Gramedia.
Gupta, R. & Brooks, H. (2013). Using Social Media for Global Security. Indiana: John Wiley&Sons, Inc.
Huysmans, J. (2000). “The European Union and the Securitization of Migration”. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, vol. 38, no. 5, pp. 751-777.
Huysmans, J. (2006). The Politics of Insecurity: Fear, Migration, and Asylum in the EU. Abingdon: Routledge.
Ireton, C. & Posetti J. (2018). Journalism, ‘Fake News’ & Disinformation. Paris: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. Available in https://en.unesco.org/sites/default/files/journalism_fake_news_disinformation_print_friendly_0_0.pdf (Accessed February 12, 2020).
Kulesza, J. (2014). “Social Media Censorship vs State Responsibility for Human Rights Violations”. In Patrut, Bogdan and Patrut, Monica (Eds), Social Media in Politics: Case Studies on the Political Power of Social Media. New York: Springer.
Kurniawan, Y. (2018). The politics of securitization in democratic Indonesia. Springer International Publishing.
Lee, A. (2016). “Pasang Surut Partisipati Politik di Dunia Maya [The Tides of Political Engagement on Cyber Spaces]”. In Tinjauan Kompas: Menatap Indonesia 2016 [Kompas Outlook: Indonesias Outlook 2016]. Jakarta: Penerbit Buku Kompas
Lee, A. (2017). “Forced Migrants, Media, and Securitization: Making Sense of the Changing Representations of Transit Asylum Seekers in Indonesian Print Media”. Journal of ASEAN Studies, 5(2), pp.75-101.
Lee, A. (2018). “Guarding the Elections Online”: New Practices, Trust, and Empowerment of Citizens Identities. Journal of Indonesian Social Sciences and Humanities, 8(1), 11-28.
Lim, M. (2013). “Many Clicks but Little Sticks: Social Media Activism in Indonesia”. In Journal of Contemporary Asia Vol. 43, No. 4: pp 636-657.
Lim, M. (2017). Freedom to Hate: Social Media, Algorithmic Enclaves, and the Rise of Tribal Nationalism in Indonesia. Critical Asian Studies, 49(3), 411-427.
Mastel. (2019). Hasil Survei Wabah Hoax Nasional 2019 [The Survei Result of National Hoax Plague 2019]. Available in https://mastel.id/hasil-survey-wabah-hoax-nasional-2019/ (Accessed in February 22, 2020).
Nash, V. (2013). “Analyzing Freedom of Expression Online: Theoretical, Empirical, and Normative Contributions”. In Dutton, William H (Ed). The Oxford Handbook of Internet Studies. Oxford; Oxford University Press. Neo, R. (2019). “The securitisation of fake news in Singapore”. In International Politics. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41311-019-00198-4
Nugroho A. 2019. “Comparative Study of Hoax Handling Policies in Indonesia and Singapore”. Proceedings of the First International Conference on Administration Science (ICAS 2019). https://doi.org/10.2991/icas-19.2019.74
Priyono, A.E, Hamid, U., Ariane, Z., & Obrigadoz. W. (2014). Media Sosial Alat Gerakan Sipil: Belajar dari Suksesi Jakarta dan Masa Depan Indonesia. Jakarta: Public Virtue Institute.
Purdey, J. (2006). Anti-Chinese Violence in Indonesia, 1996-1999. Singapore: Singapore University Press.
Ringmar, E. (2018). What are public moods?. In European Journal of Social Theory, 21(4), pp.453-469.
Salma. A. (2019). Defining Digital Literacy in the Age of Computational Propaganda and Hate Spin Politics. In The 10th IGSSCI (International Graduate Students and Scholars’ Conference in Indonesia) News Media and the Changing Social Landscape of Cintemporary Societies: How are New Media Reshaping the Whole Aspects of Life of Contemporary Societies? KnE Social Sciences, pp 323–338. doi: 10.18502/kss.v3i20.4945
Setiawan, A. (2019). “Analisis Yuridis terhadap Berita Bohong (Hoax) yang Beredar di Media Sosial Berdasar Hukum Positif” [Juridical Analysis Fake News (Hoax) in Social Media Based on Positive Law]”. In Dinamika, Vol 25, No 6, pp. 27-34. Available in http://www.riset.unisma.ac.id/index.php/jdh/article/view/3171.
Sheehan, M. (2005). International Security: An Analytical Survey. Colorado: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Siaran Pers [Press Release] No. 155/HM/KOMINFO/08/2019: Pemblokiran Layanan Data di Papua dan Papua Barat [Data Services Blocking in Papua and West Papua]. Kominfo.go.id 21/8/2019. Available in https://www.kominfo. go.id/content/detail/20821/siaran-pers-no-155hmkominfo082019-tentang-pemblokiran-layanan-data-di-papua-dan-papua-barat/0/siaran_pers (Accessed February 5, 2020).
Siaran Pers [Press Release] No. 51/HM/KOMINFO/2019: 771 Hoaks Berhasil Diidentifikasi Kemkominfo Sejak Agustus 2018 Hingga Februari 2019 [771 Hoaxes Identified by Kemkominfo since August 2018 until February 2019]. Kominfo.go.id. 13/3/2019. Available in https://kominfo.go.id/content/detail/16924/siaran-pers-no-51hmkominfo032019-tentang-771-hoaks-berhasil-diidentifikasi-kemkominfo-sejak-agustus-2018-hingga-februari-2019/0/siaran_pers (Accessed February 4, 2020).
Siaran Pers [Press Release] No.106/HM/KOMINFO/05/2019: Pembatasan Sebagian Fitur Platform Media Sosial dan Pesan Instan [Partial Throttling of Social Media and Instant Messaging Features]. Kominfo.go.id, 22/5/2019. Available in https://kominfo.go.id/content/detail/18868/siaran-pers-no-106hmkominfo052019-tentang-pembatasan-sebagian-fitur-platform-media-sosial-dan-pesan-instan/0/siaran_pers (Accessed February 5, 2020).
Siaran Pers [Press Release]: President Jokowi Absent in the Preliminary Session of the Trial on Internet Shutdown Lawsuit. Lbhpers.org, 22/01/2020. Available in http://lbhpers.org/ presiden-jokowi-mangkir-di-persidangan-perdana-gugatan-internet-shutdown/ (Accessed 26 February 2020).
Surbakti, R. (2017). “Pemilu Terbesar di Dunia [The Biggest Election in the World]. In Kompas, May 3, p.6.
Suriadi, A. (2018). “The Language of Hoax: Explosive Growth of Fake News in the Biggest Muslim Society”. Proceedings of the 2nd Internasional Conference on Culture and Language in Southeast Asia (ICCLAS 2018). Available in https://www.atlantis-press.com/proceedings/icclas-18/55913015. (Accessed January 31, 2020).
Tapsell, R. (2017). Media Power in Indonesia: Oligarchs, Citizens and The Digital Revolution. London: Rowman & Littlefield International Ltd.
The Economist Intelligence Unit. (2019). Democracy Index 2019. Available in https://www.eiu.com/public/topical_report.aspx?campaignid=democracyindex2019 (Accessed February 24, 2020).
Ulum, M. (2017). “Cyber Culture and Cyber Security Policy of Indonesia: Combining Cyber Security Civic Discourse, Tenets, and Copenhagen’s Securitization Theory Analysis. In Proceeding the 1st International Conference on Social Sciences University of Muhammadiyah Jakarta, Indonesia, 1–2 November 2017
Utami, P. (2018). “Hoax in Modern Politics: The Meaning of Hoax in Indonesian Politics and Democracy”. In Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik, Vol 22, Issue 2, p. 85-97
Waever, O. (1995). “Securitization and Desecuritization”. In Lipschutz, R.D. (Ed). On Security. New York: Columbia University Press
Waever, O. (2011). “Politics, Security, Theory”. In Security Dialogue, Vol 42 (4-5), p. 465-480.
Yanti, M. & Yusnaini. (2018). “The Narration of Digital Literacy Movement in Indonesia”. In Informasi: Kajian Ilmu Komunikasi, Vol. 48, No 2, p 243-255. https://doi.org/10.21831/informasi.v48i2.21148
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. (1976). Available in https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/ProfessionalInterest/ccpr.pdf
Universal Declaration of Human Rights. (1948). Available in https://www.un.org/en/udhr/book/pdf/udhr_booklet_en_web.pdf
Undang-Undang Nomor 11 Tahun 2008 tentang Informasi dan Transaksi Elektronik [Electronic Information and Transaction Law]. Available in https://jdih.kominfo.go.id/produk_hukum/view/id/167/t/undangundang+nomor+11+tahun+2008+tanggal+21+april++2008 (Accessed January 20, 2020)
Undang-Undang Nomor 19 Tahun 2016 tentang Perubahan Kedua Atas Undang-Undang Nomor 11 Tahun 2008 tentang Informasi dan Transaksi Elektronik [Electronic Information and Transaction Law]. Available in https://jdih.kominfo.go.id/produk_hukum/view/id/555/t/undangundang+nomor+19+tahun+2016+tanggal+25+november+2016 (Accessed January 20, 2020)
“Blokir Data Internet di Papua, Rudiantara: Ada Dasar Hukumnya [Internet Shutdown in Papua, Rudiantara: The Legal Basis is Ezisted]”, (2019), Detik.com, 24th August. Available in https://news.detik.com/berita/d-4679470/blokir-data-internet-di-papua-rudiantara-ada-dasar-hukumnya (Accessed February 3, 2020)
“Daerah Butuh Internalisasi Nilai Pancasila [Regions Needs the Internalization of Pancasila’s Value]”, (2018), Kompas, 18th October, p.3.
“False News Spread on Social Media Incited Riot in N Sumatera: Police Chief”, (2016), Thejakartapost.com, 31st July. Available in https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2016/07/31/false-news-spread-on-social-media-incited-riot-in-n-sumatra-police-chief.html (Accessed January 24, 2020)
“[Fitnah] Jokowi Nama Lahirnya Herbertus [Slander, Jokowi’s Birth Name is Herbertus]”, (2017), Turnbackhoax.id, 14th October. Available in https://turnbackhoax.id/2017/10/14/fitnah-jokowi-nama-lahirnya-herberthus/ (Accessed January 24, 2020)
“Hoaks Merusak Kualitas Pemilu [Hoax Damages the Election’s Quality]”, (2019), Kompas, 4th January, p. 1&15.
“Hoaks dan Ujaran Kebencian Jadi Teror Demokrasi Indonesia [Hoaxes and Hate Speeches Become Terror to Indonesian Democracy]. Dpr.go.id, 28/2/2019. Available in http://www.dpr.go.id/berita/detail/id/24429/t/Hoaks+dan+Ujaran+Kebencian+jadi+Teror+Demokrasi+Indonesia (Accessed February 8, 2020).
“[Hoax] KTP Pemilih Digandakan untuk Orang yang Sama Beretnis China [Hoax, Voters Identity Cards Multiplied for a Person with Chinese Ethnic]”, (2019), Turnbackhoax.id, 22nd February. Available in https://turnbackhoax.id/2017/02/04/hoax-ktp-pemilih-digandakan-untuk-orang-yang-sama-beretnis-china/ (Accessed January 25, 2020)
“Hoax”. Merriam-webster.com. Available in https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/hoax (Accessed Februaty 3, 2020).
“Indonesia to Censor Social Media during Emergency”, (2019), Thejakartapost.com, 29th October. Available ini https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2019/10/29/blocked-and-reported-indonesia-to-censor-social-media-during-emergencies.html (Accessed February 4, 2020)
“Internet Usage in Asia”, 2019. Available in https://www.internetworldstats.com/stats3.htm (Accessed January 28, 2020).
“Jakarta Riots Death Toll Rises to Eight, More than 700 Injured”, (2019), Thejakartapost.com, 23rd May. Available in https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2019/05/23/jakarta-riots-death-toll-rises-to-eight-more-than-700-injured.html (Accessed February 4, 2020)
“Jokowi Bicara Soal Hoax yang Terpa Dirinya kepada Santri [Jokowi Talks About Hoaxes Aimed at Him in front of Islamic Boarding School’s Students]”, (2018), Detik.com, 20th October. Available in https://news.detik.com/berita-jawa-tengah/d-4265343/jokowi-bicara-soal-hoax-yang-terpa-dirinya-kepada-santri (Accessed February 3, 2020)
“Kala Emosi Mendominasi [When Emotion Becomes Dominant]”, (2019), Kompas, 3rd February, p. 2.
“Pemblokiran Dinilai Rugikan Masyarakat [Internet Shutdown Harms Societies]” (2019), Kompas, 23rd August, p.8.
“Pemblokiran Masih Berlangsung di Papua dan Papua Barat [Internet in Papua and West Papua are Still Throttled]”, (2019), Kompas, 26th August, p.D.
“Presiden Ingin Polri Tuntaskan Isu Hoaks [Presidents Instruct The Indonesian National Police to Investigate Hoax]”, (2018), Kompas, 7th March, page. 3.
“[Salah] Kontainer Surat Suara yang Sudah Dicoblos [Wrong, Containers Consisting of Punched Ballot Papers]”, (2019), Turnbackhoax.id, 3rd January. Available in https://turnbackhoax.id/2019/01/03/salah-kontainer-surat-suara-yang-sudah-dicoblos/ (Accessed February 3, 2020)
“[Salah] Pergerakan Mirip ‘98’ [Wrong, 98’s a Like Movements]”, (2019), Turnbackhoax.id, 18th April. Available in https://turnbackhoax.id/2019/04/18/salah-pergerakan-mirip-98/ (Accessed February 5, 2020)
“TNI Berkomitmen Jaga Persatuan dari Ancaman Hoaks [Indonesian Armed Forces is Commited to Protect Indonesian Unity from Hoax]”, (2018), Kompas, 24th July, p.4.
“Wiranto Ancam Penyebar Hoaks Pemilu Pakai UU Terrorisme [Wiranto Threatens Election Hoax Spreaders Using the Terrorism Law]”, (2019), CNNIndonesia.com, 20th March. Available in https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20190320203726-32-379252/wiranto-ancam-penyebar-hoaks-pemilu-pakai-uu-terorisme (Accessed January 26, 2020)
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
1. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under an Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license. This license allows others to remix, adapt, and build upon the work, as long as they credit the author and license their new creations under the same terms.
2. Authors may enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal’s published version of the work (e.g., posting it to an institutional repository or including it in a book), provided there is an acknowledgment of its initial publication in this journal.
3. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their personal website) prior to and during the submission process, as this can lead to productive exchanges and increase citations of the published work (See The Effect of Open Access ).
