Complementing The Access Theory by Collaborative Approach in Indonesia Social Forestry Context

Main Article Content

Dicky Rachmawan
Francisia Saveria Sika Ery Seda
Robert Siburian

Abstract

Many previous studies examine social forestry in Indonesia from 2016-2020 which describing the factors relate to the implementation. Beyond the previous studies, this paper clustering and mapping the factors through access theory and further complement access theory by a collaborative approach in the social forestry implementation context. Qualitative desk research is used to examine 39 papers with Nvivo 12. The result shows there are two elements of the four elements of structure-relational access mechanism (SRAM) that have positive effects on social forestry implementation, while three elements of the five elements of the SRAM element give a negative effect. In turn, there are various unclustered factors which not a part of SRAM that affects social forestry implementation both positive or negative. These unclustered factors are the blank spaces of access theory which complemented by a collaborative approach, there are “participation” and “equity” which supported by “effective communication”. With a collaborative approach, the scope becomes wider that not only analyze in individual scope, but also in organizational scope, and the benefit can be seen by outside stakeholder through community contribution in social forestry implementation.

Article Details

How to Cite
Rachmawan, D., Seda, F. S. S. E., & Siburian, R. (2021). Complementing The Access Theory by Collaborative Approach in Indonesia Social Forestry Context. Jurnal Masyarakat Dan Budaya, 23(2), 141–157. https://doi.org/10.14203/jmb.v23i2.1344
Section
Articles

References

Asmin, F., Darusman, D., Ichwandi, I., dan Suharjito, D. (2019).

“Mainstreaming community-based forest management in West Sumatra:

Social Forestry, Arguments, Support, and Implementation”. Forest and

Society, 31 (1): 77-96

Candraningsih, I.A.K.., Pujaastawa, I.B.G.., dan Sudiarna, I.G.P. (2018).

“Konservasi Hutan Berbasis Kearifan Lokal di Desa Tigawasa, Kecamatan

Banjar, Kabupaten Bulelng”. Jurnal Humanis Ilmu Budaya Unud, 22:311-

319

Essougong, Urcil Papito Kenfack., Foundjem-Tita, Divine., dan Minang,

Peter A. (2019). “Addressing equity in community forestry: lessons from 20

years of implementation in Cameroon”. Ecology and Society, 24(1):9.

https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-10656-240109

Fisher, M.R., Moeliono, M., Mulyana, A., Yuliani, E.L., Adriadi, A.,

Kamaluddin, Judda, J. dan Sahide, M.A.K. (2018). “Assesing the New Social

Forestry Project in Indonesia: recognition, livelihood, and conservation”.

International Forestry Review, 20 (3): 346-361.

Garcia-López, G.A., dan Antinori, C. (2018). “Between grassroots collective

action and state mandates the hybridity of multi-level forest associations

in Mexico”. Conservation & Society, 16 (2):193-204

Hayashi, Takashi., Sawauchi, Daisuke., dan Kunii, Daisuke. (2017). “Forest

Maintenance Practices and Wood Energy Alternatives to Increase Uses of

Forest Resources in Local Initiative in Nishiwaga, Iwate, Japan”.

Sustainability, 9, 1-13. DOI: 10.3390/su9111949

Henri., H., Luchman., dan Batoro, J. (2018). “Kearifan Lokal Masyarakat

sebagai Upaya Konservasi Hutan Palawan di Kabupaten Bangka Tengah,

Bangka Belitung”. Jurnal Ilmu Lingkungan, 16 (1):49-57

Herlina, Nina., Syafrudin, Oding., dan Aangsetiana. 2016. “Kearifan Lokal

Masyarakat dalam Pengelolaan Hutan Sangiang Desa Sagarahiang

Kecamatan Darma Kabupaten Kuningan Jawa Barat”. Wanaraksa, 10 (2):

22-30.

Hondkinson, Alan. (2011). “Inclusion: A Defining Definition?” Power and

Education 3(2):179. DOI: 10.2304/power.2011.3.2.179

Humphries, Shoana., Holmes, Thomas., de Anrade, Dárlison Fernandes

Carvalho., McGrath, David., Dantas, Jeremias Batista. (2020). “Searching for

win-win forest outcomes: Learning-by-doing, financial viability, and

income growth for a community-based forest management cooperative in

the Brazilian Amazon”. World Development 125: 1-13.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2018.06.005

Kaskoyo, Hari., Abrar, Juhar Mohammed & Makoto Inoue. (2017). “Impact

of Community Forest Program in Protection Forest on Livelihood

Outcomes: a Case Study of Lampung Province, Indonesia”. Journal of

Sustainable Forestry, DOI: 10.1080/10549811.2017.1296774

Kelly, Erin C. (2018). “The Role of the Local Community on Federal Lands:

The Weaverville Community Forest”. Humboldt Journal of Social Relations.

40:163-177. Humbolt State University.

Kuncoro, M., Cahyani, D.F. (2018). “Performance of Social Forestry on

Farmer’s revenues: Lesson From Yogyakarta and Lampung, Indonesia”.

The Business and Management Review, 9 (4): 275-289. 8th International

Conference on Restructuring of Global Economy, 9-10th July 2018,

University of Oxford, UK.

Moeliono, Moira, Thuy, Pham Thu, Bong, Indah Waty, Wong, Grace Yee.,

dan Brockhaus, Maria. (2017). “Social Forestry – why and for whom? A

comparison of policies in Vietnam and Indonesia”. Forest and Society, 1

(2): 78-97. http://dx.doi.org/10.24259/fs.v1i2.2484

Mahdi, Mahdi & Shivakoti, Ganesh & Inoue, Makoto. (2017).

“Decentralization of Forest Management, Local Institutional Capacity, and

Its Effect on Access of Local People to Forest Resources”. 10.1016/B978-0-12-

805454-3.00016-5

Massiri, Sudirman Daeng., Malik, Adam., Golar, Hamzari, dan Nugroho,

Bramasto. (2020). “Institutional Capacity of Forest Management Unit in

Promoting Sustainable CommunityBased Forest Management. Case Study

of Forest Management Unit in Central Sulawesi Province, Indonesia”.

Jurnal Manajemen Hutan Tropika, 26(2), 169-177, August 2020 EISSN: 2089-

2063, DOI: 10.7226/jtfm.26.2.169

Mohammed, Abrar J., Inoue, Makoto., Shivakoti, Ganesh. (2017). “Moving

forward in collaborative forest management: Role of external actors for

sustainable Forest socio-ecological systems”. Forest Policy and Economics,

74: 13–19. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2016.10.010.

Myers, Rodd., dan Hansen, Christian Pilegaard. (2019). “Revisiting A

Theory of Access: A review”. Society & Natural Resources, DOI:

10.1080/08941920.2018.1560522

Nath, Tapan Kumar., Jashimuddin, Mohammed., dan Inoue, Makoto. (2016).

“Community-Based Forest Management (CBFM) in Bangladesh”. Swiss:

Springer Nature.

Niman, Erna Mena. (2019). “Kearifan Lokal dan Upaya Pelestarian

Lingkungan Alam”. Jurnal Pendidikan dan Kebudayaan Missio, 11 (1): 91-

106

Nurrochmat, D.R., Massijiaya, M.Y., Jaya, I.N.S., Abdulah, L., Ekayani, M.,

Astuti, E.W., dan Erbaugh, J.T. (2019). “Promoting Community Forestry to

Reduce Deforestation surround Gunung Rinjani National Park in Central

Lombok”, Indonesia. IOP Conf. Series. Earth and Environmental Science

285, 1-16. doi:10.1088/1755-1315/285/1/012014

Pambudi, Andi Setyo. (2020). “The Development of Social Forestry in

Indonesia: Policy Implementation Review”, 2007-2019. The Journal of

Indonesia Sustainable Development Planning, I (1): 57-77. doi:

https://doi.org/10.46456/jisdep.v1i1.11

Peluso, Nancy Lee., dan Ribot, Jesse. (2020). “Postscript: A Theory of Access

Revisited”. Society & Natural Resources, 33:2, 300-306, DOI:

10.1080/08941920.2019.1709929

Peters, Jeremy. (1999). "What is Inclusion?." The Review: A Journal of

Undergraduate Student Research 2 (1999): 15-21. Accessed from

https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/48615513.pdf

Pujo, S., Tubagus, F., Gunawan, B., dan Syamsudin, T.S. (2018). “Community

Capacity Building in Social Forestry Development: A Review”. Journal of

Regional and City Planning, 29 (2):113-126. DOI: 10.5614/jrep.2018.29.2.3

Qurniati, Rommy., Darmawan, Arief Utama, Rizki Bahagia., dan Inoue,

Makoto. (2019). “Poverty distribution of different types of forest-related

communities: Case study in Wan Abdul Rachman Forest Park and

mangrove forest in Sidodadi Village, Lampung Province, Indonesia”.

BIODIVERSITAS, 20 (11): 3153-3163. DOI: 10.13057/biodiv/d201107

Raihanah, Siti., Hafizianor, dan Fauzi, Hamdani. (2018). “Kearifan Lokal

Masyarakat dalam Pengelolaan Hutan Dibalai Adat Pipitak Jaya

Kalimantan Selatan”. Jurnal Sylva Scientee, 1 (2): 215-222.

Rakatama, Ari., dan Pandit, Ram. (2020). “Reviewing social forestry

schemes in Indonesia: Opportunities and challenges”. Forest Policy and

Economics, 111, 1-13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2019.102052

Reisch, Michael. (2002). “Defining Social Justice in a Socially Unjust World”.

Families in Society: the Journal of Contemporary Human Services

83(4):343-354. DOI: 10.1606/1044-3894.17

Ribot, J.C. dan Peluso, N.L. (2003). “A Theory of Access”. Rural Sociology, 68

(2): 153-181. DOI: 10.1111/j.1549-0831.2003.tb00133.xv

Royer, S. De., Noordwijk, M. Van., dan Roshetko, J.M. (2018). “Does

community-based forest management in Indonesia devolve social justice

or social costs?” International Forestry Review 20 (2):167-180

Salam, Rahayu. (2017). “Kearifan Lokal Masyarakat Adat dalam

Pengelolaan Hutan di Pulau Wangi-Wangi”. Walasuji, 8 (1): 113-128

Sardjono, M.A., dan Inoue, M. (2017). “Collaborative Governance of Forest

Resources in Indonesia: Giving Over Managerial Authority to Decision

Makers on the Sites”. Redefining Diversity and Dynamics of Natural

Resources Management in Asia 1:175-187. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-

12-805454-3.00011-6

Salampessy, Messalina., Febryano, Indra G., Ichsan, Andi Chairil., dan

Lidiawati, Ina. (2020). “Kajian Akses Masyarakat dalam Pengelolaan Galian

Pasir di Sub Daerah Aliran Sungai Ciaten, Cisadane Hulu”. Jurnal

Belantara, 3 (2): 105-115. DOI: https://doi.org/10.29303/jbl.v3i2.459

Santika, Truly., et.al. (2018). “Heterogeneous impacts of community forest

on forest conservation and poverty alleviation: Evidence from Indonesia”.

People Nature, (1):204-2019. DOI:10.1002/pan3.25

Santika, Truly., Wilson, Kerrie A., Meijaard, Erik., Indrawan, Tito P., St.John,

Freya A. V., Law, Elizabeth A., Budiharta, Sugeng., Kusworo, Ahmad.,

Friedman, Rachel., dan Struebig, Matthew J. (2019). “Heterogeneous

impacts of community forestry on forest conservation and poverty

alleviation: Evidence from Indonesia”. People and Nature. 2019;1:204–

219.DOI: 10.1002/pan3.25

Scott, James C. (1998). “Seeing Like a State”. United State of America: Yale

University

Setiajiati, Fitta., Karyaatmadja, Basoeki., Sutedja, IGNN., Kuswondho,

Harri., Sejati, Prabu Satria., dan Maharani, Ratih Solichia. (2019). “Lesson

Learned from Social Forestry Practice in a Forest and Climate Change

Project in Kalimantan, Indonesia”. IOP Conf. Series: Earth and

Environmental Science 363 (2019) 012001. doi:10.1088/1755-

1315/363/1/012001

Shohibuddin, Mohamad. (2018). “Perspektif Agraria Kritis: Teori,

Kebijakan, Dan Kajian Empiris”. Sleman (Indonesia): STPN Press.

Sinapoy, M. SAbaruddin. (2018). “Kearifan Lokal Masyarakat Adat Suku

Moronene dalam Perlindungan dan Pengelolaan Lingkungan Hidup”.

HOLREV, 2(2):513-542

Suhardjito, Didik., dan Wulandari, Christine. (2019). “A reflection of Social

Forestry in 2019: Towards inclusive and collaborative government

approaches”. Forest and Society. Vol. 3(1): 137-140, April 2019.

http://dx.doi.org/10.24259/fs.v3i1.6099

Suparno, Riyadi., Nurbaiti, Ati., (Eds), Afif, Suraya., Tarmizi, Hendarsyah.,

Mariani, Evi., dan Sastriastanti, Fidelis. (2018). “Toward Just and

Sustainable Forestry in Indonesia”. Jakarta: The JakartaPost Publishing.

Toscani, Philipp., dan Sekot, Walter. (2017). “Assessing the Economic

Situation of Small-Scale Farm Forestry in Mountain Regions A Case Study

in Austria”. Mountain Research and Development, 37 (3): 271-280

Uju, Godeliva Ferina., Bhuja, Paulus., dan Boro, Theresia Late Boro. (2019).

“Kearifan Lokal Masyarakat dalam Pengelolaan Hutan Lindung di

Kampung Wae Rebo, Desa Satar Lenda, Kabupaten Manggarai”. Jurnal

Biotropikal Sains, 16 (1):1-11

Weissberg, Leana M., Kusel, Jonathan P., dan Rodgers, Kyle A. (2018).

“From Conflict to Collaboration: Exploring Influences on Community Well-

Being”. Humboldt Journal of Social Relation, 40:178-190.

Wright, G.D., Andersson, K.P., Gibson, C.C., dan Evans, T.P. (2016).

“Decentralization can help reduce deforestation when user groups engage

with local government”. Proceeding of the National Academy of Science of

the United State of America, 113 (52), pp.14958-

14963.https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/26473011

Wulandari, Christine dan Inoue., Makoto. (2018). ”The Importance of

Social Learning for the Development of Community Based Forest

Management in Indonesia: The Case of Community Forestry in Lampung

Province”. Small-scale Forestry, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11842-018-9392-7

Wulandari, Christine., dan Kurniasih, Heni. (2019). “Community

preferences for social forestry facilitation programming in Lampung,

Indonesia”. Forest and Society, 31 (1): 114-132.

Voo, Peter., Mohammed, Abrar J., & Inoue, Makoto. (2016). “Community Use

Zone (CUZ) Model and Its Outcome in Malaysia Case Study from Crocker

Range Park, Sabah”. Journal of Management and Sustainability; 6 (3):25-33.

http://dx.doi.org/10.5539/jms.v6n3p25