Experimental Investigation of Natural Circulation Stability Phenomena in a New Loop Heat Pipe Model
Keywords:
Filling ratio, Natural circulation stability, LHP, Passive cooling system, Nuclear installationAbstract
The severe accident at the Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Power Plant in Japan in 2011 highlighted the critical need for a passive cooling system to dissipate residual decay heat following the failure of active cooling systems in the nuclear facility. The loop heat pipe (LHP) is a promising technology for such applications. The objective of this research is to understand the natural circulation stability phenomena of new LHP model under various conditions of filling ratio and heat load. The experimental methodology employed a laboratory-scale LHP model made of copper with an inner diameter of 0.104 m. The experiments were designed with filling ratios of 20%, 40%, 60%, 80%, and 100%, and hot water temperature as the evaporator heat source with variations of 60 °C, 70 °C, 80 °C, and 90 °C. The initial operating pressure was 10665.6 Pa, with a 5˚ inclination angle, demineralized water as the working fluid, and cooled by air at a velocity of 2.5 m/s. The results show that LHP natural circulation happens in two phases and stays stable. The best performance was seen at 90 °C and an 80% filling ratio. The conclusion of this research indicates that natural circulation stability in LHP operates well and occurs in two phases. This demonstrates that LHP effectively acts as a heat absorber and heat dissipator.
References
1. Widyaningsih G.A. Peraturan Presiden Nomor 22 Tahun 2017 Tentang Rencana Umum Energi Nasional. 2017. 4(1):139–52.
2. Lei D., Gao L., Zheng Y. A Novel Teaching-learning-based Optimization Algorithm for Energy-efficient Scheduling in Hybrid Flow Shop. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management. 2018. 65(2):330–40.
3. Mata J.F.C., Mesquita A.Z., Neto R.O. Comparison of the Performance, Advantages, and Disadvantages of Nuclear Power Generation Compared To Other Clean Sources of Electricity. 2017.
4. The Fukushima Daiichi Accident Report by the Director General. Vienna: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2015.
5. Kuang Y., Yang Q., Wang W. Thermal Analysis of a Heat Pipe Assisted Passive Cooling System for Spent Fuel Pools. International Journal of Refrigeration. 2022. 135:174–88.
6. Qu J., Zuo A., Liu F., Rao Z. Quantitative Analysis of Thermal Performance and Flow Characteristics of Oscillating Heat Pipes with Different Initial Pressures. Applied Thermal Engineering. 2020. 181(April):115962.
7. Tharayil T., Asirvatham L.G., Ravindran V., Wongwises S. Effect of Filling Ratio on the Performance of a Novel Miniature Loop heat Pipe Having Different Diameter Transport Lines. Applied Thermal Engineering. 2016. 106:588–600.
8. Czajkowski C., Nowak A.I., Błasiak P., Ochman A., Pietrowicz S. Experimental Study on a Large Scale Pulsating Heat Pipe Operating at High Heat Loads, Different Adiabatic Lengths and Various Filling Ratios of Acetone, Ethanol, and Water. Applied Thermal Engineering. 2020. 165:114534.
9. Wanison R., Kimura N., Murakami M., Nakai H. Thermal Performance of a Cryogenic Parallel Heat Pipe System. Cryogenics. 2022. 128(October):103589.
10. Hariyanto D., Permana S., Waris A., Mustari A.P.A., Kinoshita M., Aji I.K., et al. Irregular Pentagon Loop for Nuclear Reactor Natural Circulation System Test Apparatus. Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2024. 416(September 2023):112753.
11. Singh U., Gupta N.K. Stability Issues and Operating Limitations of Nanofluid Filled Heat Pipe: A Critical Review. Materials Today: Proceedings. 2023 (XXXX).
12. Marcel C.P., Rohde M., Van Der Hagen T.H.J.J. An Experimental Parametric Study on Natural Circulation BWRs Stability. Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2017. 318:135–46.
13. Mahdavi M., Tiari S., De Schampheleire S., Qiu S. Experimental Study of the Thermal Characteristics of a Heat Pipe. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science. 2018. 93:292–304.
14. Zohuri B. Heat Pipe Design and Technology: Modern Applications for Practical Thermal Management, Second Edition. Springer; 2016.
15. Tharayil T., Asirvatham L.G., Ravindran V., Wongwises S. Thermal Performance of Miniature Loop Heat Pipe with Graphene–water Nanofluid. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer. 2016. 93:957–68.
16. Hadi Kusuma M., Giarno, Haryanto D., Hatmoko S., Dwi Setyo Pambudi Y., Loren ButarButar S., et al. Experimental Investigation of Thermal Characteristics on a New Loop Pipe Model for Passive Cooling System. Thermal Science and Engineering Progress. 2024. 50:102555.
17. Daubner M., Knebel J.U. Mixed Convection in a Two-Phase Flow Cooling Loop. Energietechnik. 2002.
18. Kusuma M.H. Sistem Pendingin Pasif di Kolam Penyimpanan Bahan Bakar Bekas Nuklir dengan Menggunakan Pipa Kalor. Universitas Indonesia; 2017.
19. Sun Y., Xu J., Zhou H., Deng Z., Yuan Z., Cui Y., et al. Study on Flow Pattern Evolution in Outlet Heat Removal Pipe of Open Natural Circulation System. Hedongli Gongcheng/Nuclear Power Engineering. 2022. 43(2):65–9.
20. Ali S.M., Anumandla S.R., Singh S.S. Effect of Geometrical and Operating Parameters on the Performance of a Rectangular Two-phase Natural Circulation Loop. International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer. 2022. 135:106126.
21. Marcel C.P., Rohde M., Van Der Hagen T.H.J.J. An Experimental Parametric Study on Natural circulation BWRs Stability. Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2017. 318:135–46.
22. Britsch K., Anderson M., Brooks P., Sridharan K. Natural Circulation FLiBe Loop Overview. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer. 2019. 134:970–83.
