Reviewer Kalpataru competent in archaeology, ethnography, geology, biology, anthropology, history, culture, etc and also able to work professionally by upholding the ethical code of scientific publication as Reviewer. The peer-review Process of Kalpataru manuscripts is as follows:

• Every manuscript that goes to KALPATARU and goes through the publishing process is free of any cost. The process includes sending the manuscript, editing process, publishing, publication, archiving, and maintenance.

• The reviewer conducts a review (review process) manuscript according to their scientific filed. If the manuscript does not match the field of competence, a reviewer has the right to refuse and transferred to other reviewers who more competent.

• The review process uses a double-blind review which is the reviewer does not know the author’s identity and vice versa.

• The review process is done by two reviewer. The step is carried out by the E-journal system.

• The reviewer reviews the manuscript within a maximum period of 3 from the acceptance of the manuscript. The review process is based on the substance of the manuscript (article quality), including reviewing:

  • The accuracy of the title
  • The suitability of the problems, objectives, theories, methods, and discussion.
  • The clarity in the presentation of images, tables, and diagrams
  • Whether or not the manuscript has been published elsewhere.
  • The most recent references
  • Comprehensive knowledge of the authors
  • The originality of the information
  • False facts
  • Evaluate the content of the manuscript